A Man walks down a u-shape while holding up a magazine. Behind him the colors transition from dark and blue to bright and yellow.

SHIDEH GHANDEHARIZADEH / NEXTGENRADIO

Warning: This story contains a mention of suicide and may be upsetting to some readers and listeners.

MOMENTS

OF

TRUTH

This project highlights people of Cincinnati who have experienced pivotal moments that changed the direction of their lives.
 

Life begins at 46 (at least, it did for Dave)

by | Jul 18, 2025

Listen to the Story

by V Robinson | Next Generation Radio | Cincinnati Public Radio| July 2025

Click here for audio transcript

Dave Stefan: 

I lost track of this journal for a long time. And a few years later, I found it, like, “oh, wow, look at this. This stuff has come true.”

My name is Dave Stefan, and I’m a therapist, former college professor and positive psychology researcher, which basically means I study the science of happiness and try to use it for myself and for the people I meet, and clients, friends, family.

I wrestled with depression most of my life around the time that I knew that I was gay — to even say that now is like, I don’t even think about it that much, and calling myself a gay man, because back then, just verbalizing that- because for 30 years, I had been told that that’s wrong or bad.

I was working in a religious college, and had been outed at 39, and that’s what was an inciting incident to make these changes. But I was, in that time, unemployed, living with my mom, really trying to pursue the gay lifestyle, trying to find a partner. There’s actually something called a gay adolescence. I didn’t do much dating when I was actually a teenager.

[chuckles]

I waited till I was 40, which meant I felt very immature dating and just very awkward.  And all these things just weren’t happening for me. And so that led up to depression and then just feeling lost at 45 and trying to, you know, looking for signs, I guess, for things, how things could change.

The moment of truth happened when I was just about to turn 46 a month later. I came across this Economist magazine article in Barnes and Noble, basically said that we get happier as we get older. And the turning point is at 46. And so that kind of was like a light bulb for me to see that things could get better for me as I got older.

It gave me an idea that- that was a seed of a thought that, you know, eventually germinated into something really great.

I decided to do this project around happiness. But really underlying it all I wanted to be happier, just with- regardless of my circumstance, I just wanted to find greater happiness.

I had this vision journal that I kind of just cut out images to represent what I wanted to see happen as part of Project 46 and the first page

[page flipping]

is the abbey of Gethsemane. It’s a Catholic monastery in Kentucky. It’s me sitting on a bench outside that monastery, and then an image of butterflies and I wrote above it, ‘peace with God.’

[page flipping]

The next page is just through three cutouts of- representing- I wrote down on one page: ‘Partner in crime, love in life, social support, adventures.’

I took intentional steps to pursue happiness, which helped, even though things actually got worse kind of part way through that project, I say much, much worse, because I became suicidal. I was seeing a therapist. And he’s like, ‘Don’t worry about being successful or anything else, just survive.’ And that, for some reason, clicked with me, and actually had a thought, is like, ‘if I can just survive and make a difference in one other person’s life. That’s the icing on the cake.’

I met a partner, we’ve been together for 13 years. I think you just saw him pulling out of the car- driveway.

[laughs]

And, I got a job. There’s like, a long journey, but it’s very fulfilling.

I thought, because I struggled so much to figure out my life, I thought about trying to provide a community for people to help them figure out what to do with their lives.

When I looked at this journal, it was just eye-opening, because the idea of manifesting something and then creating a visual of it was, I had always believed in that process, but it was kind of evidence to me that this really works. It can really work for people, to kind of jot the ideas down, find the images. Even if you lose track of it, it just kind of seeps into your unconscious if you focus on it long enough, and then it becomes a guiding light.

When Dave Stefan realized he was gay at age 10, he spent the next 30 years trying to be anything but. He picked up Christianity as a sword to fight his orientation with. He became a senior leader at an Evangelical Christian college, where after 13 years of service, he had to resign after being outed by a colleague. This decade-plus chapter of his life had come to a frightening and abrupt close.

A psychologist works from home on his laptop.

Between research, content creation and counseling, Stefan’s inbox requires frequent monitoring. Though he’s 60 years old, he’s always ready for what his career has in store.

V ROBINSON / NEXTGENRADIO

Stefan tried to turn his life around by focusing on things he believed would make him happy. For the next two years, he took to compiling written and filmed records of his adventures abroad, filming a music video in Senegal and trekking up to Everest Base Camp. Checking off his bucket list, however, was never going to make him happy, given that he wasn’t happy with himself.

“I was, at that time, unemployed, living with my mom at 45. Really trying to pursue the gay lifestyle, and kind of what that meant for me, trying to find a partner, and all these things just weren’t happening for me,” he said. “And so that led up to depression for a couple years, and then just feeling lost at 45 and trying to, you know, looking for signs, I guess, for things, how things could change.”

And the sign came.

While browsing Barnes & Noble for self-help books with a friend, Stefan noticed The Economist’s December 2010 cover story: “The joy of growing old (or why life begins at 46).’” A month away from turning 46, this article captured Stefan’s imagination. He laid out three objectives — love in life, peace with God, a job he liked — and attaining these in the following year was going to be his “Project 46.”

To manifest his vision, Stefan bought a coil-bound notebook and began to visualize his objectives via collage. This was his “vision journal.” For love, a magazine clipping of two men camping in the forest. For peace, a photograph of him sitting outside of the Abbey of Gethsemani in Kentucky. And for his career, a picture of a Quaker meeting.

“A small group of people that will be there, not to tell you what to do, just to ask you questions,” he explained. “I thought — because I struggled so much to figure out my life — I thought about trying to provide a community for people, to help them figure out what to do with their lives.”

Stefan still has the vision journal he made 15 years ago for Project 46. He smiles as he opens it to the “partner in crime” page.

V ROBINSON / NEXTGENRADIO

With these objectives in mind, Stefan found himself with a new sense of purpose. But it didn’t get better right away. Actually, things got worse before they got better.

He became suicidal, even. Looking into the mirror one sleepless night, Stefan couldn’t even recognize the hollow-eyed man staring back at him.

“‘You only need to survive,’” Stefan’s therapist told him. “‘Don’t worry about being successful or anything else, just survive.’ And that, for some reason, clicked with me. And I actually had a thought, like, if I can just survive and make a difference in one other person’s life, that’s the icing on the cake — that’d be great.”

This is where Stefan started to make real progress and see the goals in his vision journal come to life.

“I lost track of this journal for a long time,” Stefan said. “A few years later I found it [and realized] like, ‘oh, wow, look at this — this stuff has come true.’”

A cartoon image of a woman brainstorming, captioned above as “Dreamstorming,” and beneath as “Idea Party / Dreamstorm Date.”

For Project 46, Dave Stefan put his creative mind to use through what he called a “vision journal” to collage the life he wanted.

V ROBINSON / NEXTGENRADIO

An open scrapbook. On the left, a man sits on a bench. On the right, a swarm of butterflies, captioned “Peace w/ God”.

In the “Peace With God” section of his vision journal, Stefan sits on a bench outside of the Abbey of Gethsemani (left). On the opposite page, a swarm of butterflies fly under a ray of light. Coming out has transformed Stefan’s spirituality from a force of oppression to a source of solace.

V ROBINSON / NEXTGENRADIO

Now when Stefan adventures, he has his partner of 13 years beside him. With him, Stefan doesn’t have to tell himself he’s happy, because he knows he’s happy. Looking back at the magazine clipping of the two men camping in his vision journal, he can’t help but notice the resemblance between the man in the foreground and the man he loves and lives with today.

Today, Stefan is a 60-year-old positive psychology researcher, with a coaching and counseling practice called The Come Alive Collaborative, his own version of Quaker meetings. He “produces and provides content — websites, podcasts, courses, YouTube videos, conversations, resources, and more — that helps people explore and experiment with ideas that foster a good and more meaningful life.”

A man stands in front of his backyard, smiling.

Dave Stefan relaxes on his porch, enjoying the beautiful weather on Monday, July 14, 2025. He’s journeyed around the globe, but Anderson Township remains his true home.

V ROBINSON / NEXTGENRADIO

And it all started with seeing that magazine cover and realizing his life wasn’t over.

Stefan said he “went from having nothing at 45 to just having an abundance” of emotional, intellectual and spiritual wealth.

He realized 46 isn’t too old, that there’s no such thing as “too old.”